Nanny vs. Babysitter: What’s Really in a Name?

As a nanny, one of my greatest pet peeves, which I’ll go out on a limb to say is a communal industry gripe, is when my job is reduced to “glorified babysitter.” It happens all the time. At dinner parties, family events, and even random social encounters, the topic of profession often comes up, and upon finding out that I’m a nanny, I get responses like: “You’re a nanny? But…what do you do all day?” Or better yet: “So how long have you been babysitting them?” To imply, obviously, that their understanding of childcare is turning on Nick Jr., throwing together mac’n’cheese, and texting all day.

Okay, maybe not everyone thinks that, but as someone who puts 50 plus hours a week into a job that I am deeply invested in, it can be frustrating to have that work so casually diminished.

Emily Dills, founder of The Seattle Nanny Network, worked as a nanny while in college, an experience she never forgets when sitting across from applicants she feels are undervalued. “I would have made a career out of working with children if there were more recognition in it. The nannies we represent are not just educated and experienced – they have a gift. They have chosen to dedicate their lives to working with private families in much the role of a teacher, yet there is no formal acknowledgment of that in this country. It’s frustrating.”

The biggest problem is that the majority of people don’t know what a modern nanny’s role is. Having a nanny isn’t the norm for most parents, and even in circles where it is, America doesn’t have the cultural familiarity with professional caregivers the way other countries, such as the United Kingdom, do. When we conjure images of nannies in the US, stereotypical – and often socially and historically uncomfortable – portrayals come to mind. We have turned the role into a caricature, so much so that we have no idea how to react to the real deal. It makes sense, then, that we would try to relate it to the nearest experience we are familiar with, which for most people is their neighborhood babysitter. But the two are not interchangeable.

A babysitter comes over for a few hours to monitor kids that she may or may not know well, usually so the parents can have a date night. She is there to make sure they eat and go to bed on time, and hopefully is able to make the process as fun as possible. More often than not, the majority of her babysitting time is spent while the kids are sleeping, and she is free to watch TV, talk on the phone, or do homework. She is paid in cash. She is likely on a roster of several local, trustworthy sitters the parents call from time to time, but is not indispensable to the family or an integral part of the children’s development.

On the other hand, a nanny’s role is to partner with the parents in raising their children. She is their physical extension when they are away from home. She is there almost every day, often for years, to nurture, protect, and teach the children she has been entrusted to, and has a major role in their development. While some nannies are paid under the table, most professional nannies worth their salt are salaried with benefits and, along with their employers, are complying with tax regulations. A nanny typically has years of experience in childcare, and many times has obtained degrees and certifications related to her job. Often, her expertise and wisdom is relied upon in situations where the parents might lack experience (for example, how to help a toddler transition with a newborn, potty training, dietary challenges, etc.). Nannies are often present at doctor’s appointments, sporting events, birthdays, and other family celebrations, and are a major part of the family’s life. So, why the lack of regard for such an important role?
I wanted to look into how the United Kingdom, which is the birthplace of the nanny, approaches the profession, so I reached out to Royal Nannies in London (a nanny placement agency serving the UK and making placements as far as Riyadh). Lucy, a recruitment consultant at Royal Nannies, offered a jumble of post-nominal abbreviations when asked about the applicant qualifications for their agency: “Nannies usually [have a] CACHE diploma, and often also have a NVQ diploma, MNT training, NEST training…”

Wait, what?

“And,” she added, “our nannies have to have at least five years of professional nanny experience” to qualify for application, explaining that many candidates with daycare or primary school backgrounds wish to apply, but that the families feel it necessary they have “household experience” as well as degrees. So how does all this translate into, um, plain English?
In the United Kingdom, CACHE is a two-year degree from The Council for Award in Childcare and Education. According to Royal Nannies, about half those who graduate with the degree will become nannies, while the rest go on to be employed with nurseries, schools, and hospitals. Social workers with this degree “are particularly suited to work in child protection and residential children’s units,” they claim. And, if these qualifications aren’t enough, or if your children are older, you could also hire a governess. This role is an advanced version of a nanny in England; someone who, “in contrast to a nanny, concentrates on teaching children,” both as a primary and supplementary form of education.

“We still have a lot of work to do,” Ms. Dills said, with regard to raising awareness and recognition for the professional nanny here in the US. “But we have come a long way in the two decades I’ve been in the industry. There is a lot more confidence from the applicants, if that makes sense. I see more people wearing the title of ‘nanny’ with pride because of greater understanding of their role and acceptance.”

Perhaps we can take a cue from overseas where the industry is more regulated and formerly recognized, leading to respect for those who work within it. In the meantime, the best advocates for educating others about the role of a nanny are the nannies themselves, and the families who employ them.

There is nothing wrong with the title of babysitter; I started off as one. But a babysitter watches children. A nanny helps raise them.

Copyright © 2018 Seattle Nanny Network. All Rights Reserved

Tips to Finding Good In-Home Childcare

Children are a blessing for everyone. However, childcare can be difficult, especially if you are not a stay-at-home mom or dad. One of the reasons to consider in-home childcare is for your child’s comfort and safety. Comfort and

Why Work with an Agency During Covid

A question that we often get asked is “why would I pay to work with an agency when I can find a nanny on my own?” This question has many answers, and each one is important to families

How Early is Too Early to Begin Your Childcare Search?

The journey of parenthood comes with many big decisions — and choosing childcare is one of the most important. Whether you’re expecting your first child or preparing for the end of parental leave, figuring out when to start

How to Teach Kids Mindfulness and Focus in a Hectic World – 5 Effective Strategies

Are you looking for How to Teach Kids Mindfulness? Everyone could use tools to tame anxiety in a fast-moving world. Kids who learn mindfulness and focus at a young age tend to be more capable of regulating their

10 Questions Every Nanny Should Ask

Interested in finding a nanny job? The team at National Nanny has put together the following list of questions to ask a family you are considering working with. Prepare for your interview with our nanny job interview masterclass

The Benefits of a Nanny and Why you should Consider Hiring One

Raising a child can be one of the most rewarding and challenging experiences of a person’s life. As a parent, you want to give your child the best possible care and support. Even so, balancing the demands of

Full Disclosure: The New Standard for Nanny Cams

Parents are increasingly turning to nanny cams to ensure the safety of their children with in-home care providers. This trend has been driven by media coverage of nanny abuse cases, but it is also largely influenced by the

Traveling with Your Nanny? Do’s and Dont’s

Is your family planning an upcoming holiday? If so, will you bring your nanny? Whether you have traveled with your nanny in the past or this is uncharted territory, it’s important to set clear boundaries and guidelines before

New Year, New Routine: Is It Time to Hire a Nanny?

A new year is the perfect time to reassess what’s working for your family—and what isn’t. As schedules change and children grow, many parents begin to wonder if their current childcare still supports their family’s wellbeing. If things

Reflecting on the Year: How to Strengthen the Family–Nanny Relationship

As the year wraps up, families and nannies have a chance to reflect on their work together. The family–nanny relationship mixes professionalism with trust and care. Taking time to reflect strengthens communication, deepens respect, and sets the stage

The Fastest Way to Hire a Nanny in Seattle (Even If You Need Care ASAP)

When childcare falls through unexpectedly, it can feel overwhelming. Maybe your nanny gave notice, your schedule changed, or you suddenly need full-time care right away. In situations like this, speed matters—but so does making the right choice. The

My Home is Someone’s Workplace

I took a deep dive recently into the local and national movements that are taking place around the employer and domestic worker relationship and I can say, there are some exciting changes afoot. Forays include attending a forum

Supercharge Your Nanny Career: Tools to Unleash Professional Growth

Find out how to supercharge your nanny career and unleash professional growth with free classes, online resources, paid education, and industry-specific in-person events. How does a nanny supercharge their career and unleash professional growth? One thing that sets

Guest Blog: Packing For Birth Day Success – A Guide For Partners

Guest blog introduction by Kiersten Moen: Last April, I started out my day with a routine doctor’s visit and ended it by being admitted to the hospital in week 32 of my pregnancy with twins.  This was the

5 Seattle Fall Activities That Make Kids Actually Want to Go Outside

It’s Saturday morning in Seattle. The rain is tapping on the windows. Your kids are glued to their screens, and you’re wondering if moving to the PNW to raise “outdoor kids” was really such a great idea. Sound

Employing a Nanny during COVID-19

“Do I have to wear a mask inside the house” and “Do I have to pay the nanny if I ask them to stay home because a family member is not feeling well” – are just a few

Looking for a Nanny? Here Are Qualities To Prioritize

Do you need help with your newborn or a childcare provider to care for the family while you’re away? One option you can consider is hiring a nanny. Most caretakers today are trained to manage family needs, so

Why Elite Nannies Are Fleeing Social Media Hiring Platforms 

Premium childcare professionals are increasingly avoiding Facebook and other marketplace apps. Understanding this shift has the potential to transform your family’s search for quality care.  Many parents describe spending weeks scrolling through Facebook nanny groups and marketplace apps,

Survival Guide: Long Flights with Kids

Navigate long flights with kids like a pro with this survival guide When you have in-laws who live on the other side of the world, long flights with little ones are just a part of life. My first

Part-Time vs Full-Time Nannies: What Seattle Families Prefer Now

If you’ve recently found yourself sitting at the kitchen table with a cup of coffee, staring at a childcare spreadsheet that somehow grew to seventeen columns — welcome. You’re not alone. Across Seattle, families are asking the same