Nanny Interviews: Look for these 4 things

When hiring a nanny for your children, it’s critical to find the right fit for your family. A resume or profile is not a person, and can’t always tell you everything you need to know. Fit often has more to do with interpersonal connections, communication style, and care philosophy. 

With the rise of video interviews, candidate profiles, and virtual nanny services, families are not always learning enough about how that nanny will fit into their home dynamic. You can’t know until you meet them in person.

So, you’ve invited a candidate to your home; what should you be looking for? Beyond their resume, here are a few traits that will be strong indicators of a nanny’s skill and abilities, even during a first meeting.

Cool amongst Chaos nanny blog image

When you are interviewing a nanny, it can be a high-pressure situation. First meetings between kids and a stranger can be stressful, and if you find your infant fussy in their arms, your toddler shy, or your preschooler suddenly in the midst of a meltdown, don’t panic. Instead of reading into your child’s reaction, focus on the nanny’s face. If they are calm, relaxed, and positive in the face of an upset child, that will tell you much more about their comfort with the role than a child’s separation anxiety. This will also indicate competence in an emergency, which is critical for the safe care of your child. 

Developmental Knowledge 

By hiring a nanny who has worked with a variety of age groups or has some training or education in child development, you are ensuring that this person will know how to enrich your child at any age. It can also be an indicator of long-term retention, as they will know how to shift their care style as your child’s needs change. When interviewing candidates, ask them to give examples of activities/toys for your child’s age group, and then ask them why those things are beneficial. Even better, encourage them to play with your child at the moment! An experienced nanny will be able to explain the developmental value of activities while demonstrating their particular care style/philosophy.

Classroom Experience

Many nannies start their career as in-home caregivers by transitioning from a childcare facility, school, or daycare. Some families write these professionals off since they have “never been a nanny before.” That is doing these families (and teachers) a disservice, as the skills developed in classrooms and daycares are incredibly transferable and require a higher degree of multitasking, communication, and management skills. Imagine a lead teacher–caring for 12 toddlers; communicating with 24 parents; maintaining their classroom, preparing meals, and creating curriculum and detailed observations for each child—being told they aren’t qualified to be a nanny to one toddler in someone’s home. Keeping an open mind to different sources of experience can lead to you creating a lasting relationship for your entire family. 

Guarantee Quality with a Professional Nanny Agency 

Searching for a nanny on your own can be incredibly time-consuming and frustrating, and your time is valuable. You can’t know the most critical details about a candidate from a social media post or platform profile.

Online background checks only tell part of the story and are a poor substitute for agency checks as they are bound to strict regulations. The same goes for references, which should be verified for authenticity—you should be wary of a candidate presents a letter of recommendation without contact information included.

Working with an established and reputable agency ensures quality, due diligence, and access to resources (such as payroll and tax guidance, employee retention tips, and advocacy that protects you and your employee). A professional nanny agency understands the market and can guide you through the hiring process, taking on the heavy lifting of vetting, and making sure you can focus on the right thing: the fit.

Essential Guide: Preparing for Holiday Travel as a Professional Nanny

Navigating Holiday Travel With Your Employer Family The holidays can bring big changes to family routines—and for many professional nannies, that includes traveling with the family. Whether it’s a ski trip or a long visit with relatives, holiday

How Specialized Childcare Brings Peace of Mind to Physician Families

Being a medical professional comes with incredible rewards—but also unique challenges. Long hours, on-call schedules, and emergency shifts can make it extremely difficult to maintain consistent childcare. When a pager goes off at 2 AM, plans for the

The Hidden Value of Hiring a Nanny in the Fall (Before the Holiday Rush)

Why Fall Is a Great Time to Hire a Nanny As summer winds down and school routines pick back up, fall becomes a time when families settle into a new rhythm. What many parents don’t realize is that

Sleep Training for Nannies: A Step-by-Step Approach

This blog post provides nannies with a step-by-step approach to sleep training. A nanny who has sleep training can be a solution for many families seeking relief. From assessing sleep needs to implementing a personalized sleep training

5 Seattle Fall Activities That Make Kids Actually Want to Go Outside

It’s Saturday morning in Seattle. The rain is tapping on the windows. Your kids are glued to their screens, and you’re wondering if moving to the PNW to raise “outdoor kids” was really such a great idea. Sound

What It Takes to Become a Professional Nanny

We’re excited to introduce this insightful guide from Nurture Haven Nannies & Co, shining a spotlight on what it truly takes to become a professional nanny in today’s childcare landscape. In this thoughtful article, they break down the

The New Sick Leave Law and your Nanny

Is being a nanny even a real job? Does a nanny or sitter have the same rights as an employee of a company? Many employers have questions about how the new law impacts the employment of their nanny.

Want to Offer Your Nanny Health and Other Insurance Plans? Here’s How

The pandemic has shined a light on a critical fact: affordable healthcare is essential. This applies to everyone you know, including your nanny. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) says that only employers who have 50 or more full-time

How Seattle Parents Balance Career and Childcare Without Burning Out

Seattle is a fast-moving city. In Seattle, parents are constantly balancing demanding careers with raising children they deeply love. From tech offices to healthcare, education, and small businesses, many families are managing two full-time worlds at once. The

“Virtual Nanny:” the break Parents need

Strong Olivia and Lion are characters that Ms. Redmond, a Seattle Public School teacher, created to virtually interact with her students, or “scholars” as she calls them. She is a traditional classroom teacher but watching her on video

Supporting Sibling Dynamics as a Nanny: Strategies for Peaceful Play

Sibling relationships are some of the most important—and challenging—connections children experience. For nannies caring for multiple children, supporting healthy sibling dynamics is key to creating a calm, respectful, and happy home. Below are simple, practical strategies to help

Gentle Parenting and Professional Childcare: How They Work Together

If you’ve found yourself scrolling through parenting forums at midnight, trying to figure out how to stay true to your gentle parenting values while also finding a childcare provider who truly gets it — you are absolutely not

Gratitude in Childcare: Teaching Thankfulness Through Daily Routines

Cultivating Gratitude in Young Children Gratitude helps children notice the good in their lives — turning simple moments into something meaningful. It doesn’t take big lessons or fancy tools. Just small, intentional moments in daily life. Even in

Helpful Tips to Introduce Your Child to Your Nanny

When you bring someone new, like a nanny, into your home, your child’s first reaction may be apprehension or resistance. This reaction is normal, especially if your child isn’t used to an outsider in their life. To make

5 Signs You Need Professional Help with Your Childcare Search

If you’re a busy physician family, finding the right nanny can feel impossible — endless late‑night profile browsing, interviews, vetting… and still no one you trust. Childcare should give you peace of mind, not become another full-time job.

How to Teach Kids Mindfulness and Focus in a Hectic World – 5 Effective Strategies

Are you looking for How to Teach Kids Mindfulness? Everyone could use tools to tame anxiety in a fast-moving world. Kids who learn mindfulness and focus at a young age tend to be more capable of regulating their

Average Nanny Costs in Seattle (2026 Guide): What Families Should Really Expect to Pay

If you’ve started researching nanny costs in Seattle, you’ve probably already noticed one thing: the numbers are all over the place. One family says they pay $30–35/hour. Another says $40/hour is standard. Some include benefits, others don’t. Suddenly,

Guest Blog: The Effects of COVID-19 on Nannies and the Family Dynamic

It’s been more than a year since COVID-19 forced the world into isolation, and everyone is feeling the effects—both mentally and physically. Many families are struggling to maintain some semblance of “normal” life while juggling work, childcare, schoolwork,

How to Build a Strong Relationship with your Nanny

We’re excited to feature a guest post from Christine Wisdom of Olive You Nanny Milwaukee. Christine shares practical, heartfelt guidance on a topic every family can benefit from: how to build a strong, lasting relationship with your nanny.

Nanny Contracts: Game-Changing Announcement

We have exciting news to share! There has been a recent game-changing development that has the potential to revolutionize nanny work. In this post, we will discuss the recent announcement from the US Dept of Labor, the importance